Vintage 80s 90s Pencil Plush Toy I’m A Big Time Writer Author Gift Funny

$49.77

Vintage | Toys & Hobbies | Stuffed Animals |

 

Vintage Knickerbocker I’m Mr Nonsense Plush Stuffed Animal Toy Roger Hargreaves

$29.99

Vintage | Toys & Hobbies | Stuffed Animals |

 

Vintage Toy Rubber Face Hobo Dog Plush No Tags "I deal it's a wonderful Toy ?"

$124.99

Vintage | Toys & Hobbies | Stuffed Animals |

 

Vintage Dakin Garfield Plush I'm Not Fat I'm UnderTall 1981 Stuffed Toy Tag

$27.08

Vintage | Toys & Hobbies | Stuffed Animals |

 

I’m Mr Noisey Plush Vintage Toy Made In Korea Knickerbocker

$9.97

Vintage | Toys & Hobbies | Stuffed Animals |

 

Vintage 1970s American Toy & Novelty Co Polar Bear Red Shirt "I love you" 15"

$11.99

Vintage | Toys & Hobbies | Stuffed Animals |

 

Rare Vintage Superior Toy and Novelty Pink Plush Stuffed I Love You Elephant 9"

$18.18

Vintage | Toys & Hobbies | Stuffed Animals |

 

I Fleminger Plush Stuffed Animal Dog "Penny" 1976 Rare Vintage Toy

$22.00

Vintage | Toys & Hobbies | Stuffed Animals |

 

SUPER RARE Vintage 80's MOC House I.K.C 10" Alligator Plush Toy Japan NWT

$74.95

Vintage | Toys & Hobbies | Stuffed Animals |

 

Vintage Y2K Millennium DE' BUGABLE COLLECTION Plush Toy I'Mok-De,Bug 1999

$6.95

Vintage | Toys & Hobbies | Stuffed Animals |

 

Vintage Donkey Plush Toy Purple Kitsch Couple Carnival Prize Korea A.I. Novelty

$90.00

Vintage | Toys & Hobbies | Stuffed Animals |

 

Vintage Dakin Vibrating Plush Dog Toy with Bone 'Pull My Toy I Wiggle'

$9.95

Vintage | Toys & Hobbies | Stuffed Animals |

 

Vintage I’M SLURP Red Blue Eyes Plush Furry Monster Toy Stuffed Antlers

$85.00

Vintage | Toys & Hobbies | Stuffed Animals |

 

Vintage 1979 NorthAmerican Bear Trench Coat Mr.Bear/Full House Humphrey Beargart

$50.00

Vintage | Toys & Hobbies | Stuffed Animals |

 

Dakin 7-1/2 inch Great America Tiger I’m A Little Tuffy Plush Toy

$15.00

Vintage | Toys & Hobbies | Stuffed Animals |

 

SUPER RARE Vintage 80's MOC House I.K.C 10" Alligator Plush Toy Japan

$74.99

Vintage | Toys & Hobbies | Stuffed Animals |

 

Vintage Clown Stuffed Plush Toy Made in Korea A-I Novelty Los Angeles 1978 Doll

$25.00

Vintage | Toys & Hobbies | Stuffed Animals |

 

Vintage E.L.I. INC Green Frog Plush Sunglasses Korea Stuffed Animal Toy

$9.59

Vintage | Toys & Hobbies | Stuffed Animals |

 

Vintage 1990 Avon 10” Plush Dog Toy “I❤️You” Tag

$8.99

Vintage | Toys & Hobbies | Stuffed Animals |

 

Vintage 1982 A&B Novelty I Love You Bear Plush 16" Teddy Stuffed Animal Toy

$15.95

Vintage | Toys & Hobbies | Stuffed Animals |

 

Garfield Vintage Head Turns Suction Cup I'm Climbing The Walls For You Plush Toy

$24.99

Vintage | Toys & Hobbies | Stuffed Animals |

 

Vintage Y2K Millennium DE' BUGABLE COLLECTION Plush Toy I'Mok-De,Bug 1999

$9.99

Vintage | Toys & Hobbies | Stuffed Animals |

 

Vintage 1950’s Mohair Articulated Poodle Plush Toy Beige Flex-i-Pets 14 x 11

$59.50

Vintage | Toys & Hobbies | Stuffed Animals |

 

Vintage Geoffrey Giraffe I'm A Toy's R Us Kid Stuffed 18" Plush Mighty Star

$22.99

Vintage | Toys & Hobbies | Stuffed Animals |

 

Vintage Joy Toy Beige Teddy Bear Valentine Red Lace Heart Bow Tie I Love You 10"

$7.95

Vintage | Toys & Hobbies | Stuffed Animals |

 

Vintage 90's I Love You Barney Playskool Plush Toy Barney And Friends

$12.99

Vintage | Toys & Hobbies | Stuffed Animals |

 

VINTAGE 1984 A-I Novelty Elephant Plush Grey Stuffed Animal Toy 8" Korea RARE

$19.00

Vintage | Toys & Hobbies | Stuffed Animals |

 

Vintage Barney Plush 10 in Doll Kids Toy "I Love You"

$14.99

Vintage | Toys & Hobbies | Stuffed Animals |

 

Kent Toys 1983 Moodie I Am Extravagant Plush Toy Purple Plush NEW

$40.00

Vintage | Toys & Hobbies | Stuffed Animals |

 

Vtg Avon Puppy Plush Rufus 9” Stuffed St Bernard Dog I Love You Collar 1990s Toy

$19.99

Vintage | Toys & Hobbies | Stuffed Animals |

 

Australia Souvenir Kangaroo Plush Joey Stuffed Animal Boomerang I Love AUS Tag

$11.00

Vintage | Toys & Hobbies | Stuffed Animals |

 

Vintage Ace Novelty Blue Teddy Bear With Heart Stuffed Animal Toy I Love You

$15.00

Vintage | Toys & Hobbies | Stuffed Animals |

 

Vintage Kel-Toy Jointed Teddy Bear I Love You Valentine Plush Hearts W/Tag Gift

$19.00

Vintage | Toys & Hobbies | Stuffed Animals |

 

HTF VTG 1960s “I'm Your Bippy” Laugh-In RED Shag Plush Toy Ice Capades *READ*

$45.80

Vintage | Toys & Hobbies | Stuffed Animals |

 

Vintage Plush Monkey Doll, 2001 P.I.I. Spider Monkey Black Hugger Y2K Toy

$11.25

Vintage | Toys & Hobbies | Stuffed Animals |

 

Vintage 1982 Wallace Berrie I Love You Devil Plush Toy With Cape

$25.00

Vintage | Toys & Hobbies | Stuffed Animals |

 

Vintage Ziggy Easter Bunny Plush Doll I Love You Russ Berrie 9” Stuffed Toy

$11.01

Vintage | Toys & Hobbies | Stuffed Animals |

 

Vintage Lyon BARNEY Purple Dinosaur Plush Stuffed Toy I Love You - WORKS

$20.00

Vintage | Toys & Hobbies | Stuffed Animals |

 

Vintage Pink Bear Ich Liebe Dich (I love you) Germany Plush Toy

$23.00

Vintage | Toys & Hobbies | Stuffed Animals |

 

Vintage Singing Barney the Dinosaur 10" I Love You Heart Purple Stuffed Toy

$14.99

Vintage | Toys & Hobbies | Stuffed Animals |

 

I'm Slurp Pink Plush Toy With Green Feet Blood Shot Eyes Vintage Used Circa 60s

$125.00

Vintage | Toys & Hobbies | Stuffed Animals |

 

Vintage I’M SLURP Tan Spectacular Plush Furry Monster Bloodshot Eyes Toy READ

$52.00

Vintage | Toys & Hobbies | Stuffed Animals |

 

Vintage 1982 Wallace Berrie I Love You Devil Plush Toy With Cape

$19.99

Vintage | Toys & Hobbies | Stuffed Animals |

 

Vintage Ziggy "I Love You" Plush Stuffed Animal Toy American Greetings 1986

$10.99

Vintage | Toys & Hobbies | Stuffed Animals |

 

Vintage Pet Toy Inc I'm Up In Arms Over You Red 6 Leg Octopus Plush Gund

$150.00

Vintage | Toys & Hobbies | Stuffed Animals |

 

Mini Teddy Bear Plush Vintage I Love You Shirt Stuffed Toy VTG

$13.14

Vintage | Toys & Hobbies | Stuffed Animals |

 

Vintage Pink 1985 Animal Toy Imports Inc. I Love You Plush Made In Taiwan NWT

$8.00

Vintage | Toys & Hobbies | Stuffed Animals |

 

Vintage Allentown Toy Co. 12" Rag Doll Clown 'I Like You' with Lace and Pom Pom

$22.50

Vintage | Toys & Hobbies | Stuffed Animals |

 

Vintage Charlie Brown Fabric Toy 'I Need all the Friends I Can Get' Hard to Find

$19.99

Vintage | Toys & Hobbies | Stuffed Animals |

 

Vintage 1978 A.I. Novelty CO. Baby Hippo Hippopotamus 12" Plush Korea

$9.75

Vintage | Toys & Hobbies | Stuffed Animals |

 

Vintage 1979 SMURF Peyo Wallace Berrie & Co 11" Plush Toy I Smurf You T Shirt

$32.14

Vintage | Toys & Hobbies | Stuffed Animals |

 

Vintage Carnival Prize Plush Stuffed Toy Swim Ring Life Buoy Novelty I LOVE YOU

$8.99

Vintage | Toys & Hobbies | Stuffed Animals |

 

Vintage 1992 Fable Toy Corp Stuffed Tiger “ I ❤️ You” Valentines Day Gift

$16.95

Vintage | Toys & Hobbies | Stuffed Animals |

 

Vintage 1998 T.W.I.E. Lion Plush Pillow Angel Toy Co.

$29.99

Vintage | Toys & Hobbies | Stuffed Animals |

 

VINTAGE JESTIA NO. 725 JAPAN I'M YOUR SNUGGLE-Y TOY DOG

$17.99

Vintage | Toys & Hobbies | Stuffed Animals |

 

1988 Vintage ZIGGY Doll Plush Toy Christmas "I Love You!" Santa

$14.25

Vintage | Toys & Hobbies | Stuffed Animals |

 

Vintage 2005 P.I.I Plush Monkey Toy Beige Black 10 Inches

$16.00

Vintage | Toys & Hobbies | Stuffed Animals |

 

Vintage Allentown Toy Bear I Love You Plush Stuff Animal 9" sitting

$18.90

Vintage | Toys & Hobbies | Stuffed Animals |

 

Vintage Pink Teddy Bear Plush I Love PA Pennsylvania Souvenir 6” Toy

$14.99

Vintage | Toys & Hobbies | Stuffed Animals |

 

Vintage Sid Fannie May Bear I Love Chocolate Plush Stuffed Animal Toy 10"

$13.12

Vintage | Toys & Hobbies | Stuffed Animals |

 

Vtg I'm Hippie Beatnik Beret Carnival Prize Felt Stuffed Animal Plush Toy 60s

$67.99

Vintage | Toys & Hobbies | Stuffed Animals |

 

Mattel Ice Tickle Bear Pink Tummy Plush Toy NOS Vtg 1993 Pink I Love You

$19.99

Vintage | Toys & Hobbies | Stuffed Animals |

 

Vintage I Smurf You Peyo Applause Wallace Berrie Plush Stuffed Toy 1983 NWT

$19.99

Vintage | Toys & Hobbies | Stuffed Animals |

 

VINTAGE HALLOWEEN "I LOVE YOU" VAMPIRE ZIGGY 4" Plush Stuffed DOLL TOY 1993

$7.46

Vintage | Toys & Hobbies | Stuffed Animals |

 

VINTAGE ITALY PUPPY DOG G.I.R. PERTEGATO VICENZA BROWN TOY STUFFED ANIMAL PLUSH

$28.50

Vintage | Toys & Hobbies | Stuffed Animals |

 

Vintage 1994 Guess How Much I Love You Nutbrown Hare Plush Rabbit Toy

$14.25

Vintage | Toys & Hobbies | Stuffed Animals |

 

1980s Vintage 12” Yellow Sprite “I Need Your Love” Rubber Face By Animal Toy

$29.00

Vintage | Toys & Hobbies | Stuffed Animals |

 

1965 Stuffed Animal Plush Lion Toy Flex I Pets Cute Flex-I-pets Plush

$14.99

Vintage | Toys & Hobbies | Stuffed Animals |

 

New Vintage Woody Woodpecker Plush w/ Heart 9" I LOVE YOU 2001 Toy Network P19

$19.91

Vintage | Toys & Hobbies | Stuffed Animals |

 

Vintage C.M. Paula Monkey Plush Hug Me I Hug Back Stuffed Animal Korea 90s Toy

$19.47

Vintage | Toys & Hobbies | Stuffed Animals |

 

Sesame Street Magic Lights Ernie I Love Duckie Vintage Plush Toy (1997) (Tyco)

$14.83

Vintage | Toys & Hobbies | Stuffed Animals |

 

Vintage Lion Plush Toy Carnival Style Allentown Toy Mfg RARE I Love You Stuffed

$13.49

Vintage | Toys & Hobbies | Stuffed Animals |

 

Vintage 1982 A&B Novelty I Love You Bear Plush 16" Teddy Stuffed Animal Toy

$19.95

Vintage | Toys & Hobbies | Stuffed Animals |

 

Vtg 1980s S.A.I Toy Large Teddy Bear Plush Polar White Animal Brown Paws RARE

$40.00

Vintage | Toys & Hobbies | Stuffed Animals |

 

Vintage G.I.R. Pertegato Vincenza Felted Wired Cow Toy Pupi Black - Gray

$99.99

Vintage | Toys & Hobbies | Stuffed Animals |

 

VNTG PAWS 1978 GARFIELD I Love You Heart Plush Toy

$14.00

Vintage | Toys & Hobbies | Stuffed Animals |

 

Vintage Ziggy Doll Plush Christmas Santa I Love You 1988 Toy Stuffed Holidays 7”

$17.99

Vintage | Toys & Hobbies | Stuffed Animals |

 

Vintage Teddy Bear I Love You White Red Plush Stuffed Toy Star Shape 7 Inch

$14.99

Vintage | Toys & Hobbies | Stuffed Animals |

 

Vintage 1998 T.W.I.E Stuffed Teddy Bear Pillow

$20.00

Vintage | Toys & Hobbies | Stuffed Animals |

 

Vintage ZIGGY Doll Plush Toy I Love You Christmas Santa Collectible 7 w TAG

$14.99

Vintage | Toys & Hobbies | Stuffed Animals |

 

Vintage 1989 Playskool I LOVE YOU Nosy Bears White Pink Candy Heart Plush 8"

$23.00

Vintage | Toys & Hobbies | Stuffed Animals |

 

Superior Toy And Novelty Vintage White Hearts Valentine I Love Ya’ Stuffed Bear

$17.00

Vintage | Toys & Hobbies | Stuffed Animals |

 

1965 Leonis Brown Monkey Stuffed Animal Plush Chimp Toy Flex I Pets Cute

$24.99

Vintage | Toys & Hobbies | Stuffed Animals |

 

I’m A Toys R Us Kid Brown Bear Plush 1982 Vintage Stuffed Animal Fun Farm

$29.99

Vintage | Toys & Hobbies | Stuffed Animals |

 

VINTAGE A.I. NOVELTY 1983 GRAY ELEPHANT BLUE EYES PLUSH TOY 7" RARE (B42)

$34.00

Vintage | Toys & Hobbies | Stuffed Animals |

 

Rare 1966 Turquoise I'm Slurp Stuffed Toy From Spectacular Products Inc. Vintage

$190.00

Vintage | Toys & Hobbies | Stuffed Animals |

 

Vintage 1992 Barney Singing I Love You Plush Musical Dinosaur Toy UNTESTED

$16.31

Vintage | Toys & Hobbies | Stuffed Animals |

 

Valentines Day Dalmatian Puppy Stuffed Toy Heart " I Love You" Vintage

$7.48

Vintage | Toys & Hobbies | Stuffed Animals |

 

Vintage Walmart 13" Tuxedo Cat w/Glitter Bow & I Love You Bow Plush Toy

$162.50

Vintage | Toys & Hobbies | Stuffed Animals |

 

Vintage 1982 Commonwealth Orange “I’m A Noid” Stuffed Animal Plush Toy Novelty

$24.99

Vintage | Toys & Hobbies | Stuffed Animals |

 

Vintage 1998 TWIE Pillow RARE Koala 12" square T.W.I.E. Angel Toy Corporation

$9.99

Vintage | Toys & Hobbies | Stuffed Animals |

 

Block Head Plush Toy By Fine Toy Co Smack ‘um Sings “I Feel Good” No Tags Works

$5.60

Vintage | Toys & Hobbies | Stuffed Animals |

 

Vintage Stuffed Bear Wearing I Love To Run Jogging Suit Commonwealth PA Toy 15"

$112.50

Vintage | Toys & Hobbies | Stuffed Animals |

 

Vtg Russ Berrie I Wuv You This Much Puppy Dog Plush Stuffed Animal Toy Yellow 7”

$20.00

Vintage | Toys & Hobbies | Stuffed Animals |

 

Bullwinkle Soft Sculpture I Love You Valentine Stuffed Animal Toy VINTAGE NEW

$12.95

Vintage | Toys & Hobbies | Stuffed Animals |

 

Vtg 1992 Dakin Barney Plush 21" Purple Dinosaur Toy Stuffed Animal "I Love You"

$19.99

Vintage | Toys & Hobbies | Stuffed Animals |

 

Poochie Vintage 8” Dog Plush 1983 Mattel I love dancing NWT

$99.99

Vintage | Toys & Hobbies | Stuffed Animals |

 

Vtg 80s C.M Paula Co Monster Plush Holding Sign “I Lust You”

$32.00

Vintage | Toys & Hobbies | Stuffed Animals |

 

TAC I & D 1991 Vintage Mama Koala & Baby Plush

$32.30

Vintage | Toys & Hobbies | Stuffed Animals |

 

Garfield Vintage 9”Plush 1978-1981 “I Don’t Do Windows” By Dakin

$19.99

Vintage | Toys & Hobbies | Stuffed Animals |