George Washington Carver Authenticated Ink REJECTED 1896 Indian Head Penny Card

$8.99

Trading Card Singles | Sports Trading Cards | Sports Mem, Cards & Fan Shop |

 

Vintage 10 Cent Beer Night Baseball Cleveland Indians Flyer Replica Print Gift

$8.98

Prints | Vintage Sports Memorabilia | Sports Mem, Cards & Fan Shop |

 

Antigua Cleveland Indians Cotton And Polyester Quarter Zip Mens XXL Read Desc.

$22.99

Baseball-MLB | Fan Apparel & Souvenirs | Sports Mem, Cards & Fan Shop |

 

Rogers Hornsby Authenticated Ink 1896 Indian Head Penny Birth Relic No Coin

$11.99

Trading Card Singles | Sports Trading Cards | Sports Mem, Cards & Fan Shop |

 

Henry W. Longfellow Authenticated Ink REJECTED 1899 Indian Head Penny Card

$8.00

Trading Card Singles | Sports Trading Cards | Sports Mem, Cards & Fan Shop |

 

2023 Pieces of the Past ~ 1891 Indian Head Cent Relic ~~ LOOK!

$18.00

Trading Card Singles | Sports Trading Cards | Sports Mem, Cards & Fan Shop |

 

John Bell Hood Authenticated Ink REJECTED 1899 Indian Head Penny Card

$8.00

Trading Card Singles | Sports Trading Cards | Sports Mem, Cards & Fan Shop |

 

William Cody Authenticated Ink REJECTED 1872 Indian Head Penny Card-NO COIN

$6.00

Trading Card Singles | Sports Trading Cards | Sports Mem, Cards & Fan Shop |

 

Charles Darwin REJECTED Authenticated Ink 1899 Indian Head Cent Card

$7.00

State Elections | Trading Card Singles | Collectibles | Sports Trading Cards | US | Sports Mem, Cards & Fan Shop | Historical Memorabilia | Political |

 

2020 UD GOODWIN CHAMPIONS 1900 INDIAN HEAD CENT HISTORIC CURRENCY RELIC CASE HIT

$84.99

Trading Card Singles | Sports Trading Cards | Sports Mem, Cards & Fan Shop |

 

1907 Indian Penny MS-60+ RB. Nice surfaces.

$41.00

Balls | Autographs-Original | Baseball-MLB | Sports Mem, Cards & Fan Shop |

 

Alexander Graham Bell REJECTED Authenticated Ink 1899 Indian Head Cent Card

$7.00

State Elections | Trading Card Singles | Collectibles | Sports Trading Cards | US | Sports Mem, Cards & Fan Shop | Historical Memorabilia | Political |

 

Pat Garrett Authenticated Ink REJECTED 1899 Indian Head Penny Card

$10.00

Trading Card Singles | Sports Trading Cards | Sports Mem, Cards & Fan Shop |

 

Vintage MLB Cleveland Indians Sketchbook 1964 75 Cents Baseball Booklet

$37.99

Baseball - MLB | Vintage Sports Memorabilia | Sports Mem, Cards & Fan Shop | Publications | Programs |

 

Ultimate Sports Memorabilia Coin Collection: 2 Indian Head, 10 Wheat Pennies, 2

$53.99

Other Vintage Sports Mem | Vintage Sports Memorabilia | Sports Mem, Cards & Fan Shop |

 

2012 Topps Gypsy Queen Indian Head Penny Relic /10 Clayton Kershaw IHP-CK 🔥🔥

$200.00

Trading Card Singles | Sports Trading Cards | Sports Mem, Cards & Fan Shop |

 

Eisenhower Susan B Kennedy Franklin Liberty Washington Buffalo - SIngles & Sets

$5.59

Sticker Singles | Sports Mem, Cards & Fan Shop | Sports Stickers, Collections & Albums |

 

Tyrus "TY" Cobb Authenticated Ink 1886 Indian Head Birth Year Card NO COIN!

$13.99

Trading Card Singles | Sports Trading Cards | Sports Mem, Cards & Fan Shop |

 

Wilbur Wright Authenticated Ink REJECTED 1903 Indian Head Penny Card

$8.00

Trading Card Singles | Sports Trading Cards | Sports Mem, Cards & Fan Shop |

 

2-1907 & 1908 INDIAN HEAD CENT SET OF 2 CIRCULATED [SEE SCAN FOR CONDITION]

$7.99

Trading Card Singles | Sports Trading Cards | Sports Mem, Cards & Fan Shop |

 

Homage Cleveland Indians Stadium 10 Cent Beer Night Tank Top Medium

$10.50

Baseball-MLB | Fan Apparel & Souvenirs | Sports Mem, Cards & Fan Shop |

 

John Quincy Adams Authenticated Ink REJECTED 1899 Indian Head Penny Card

$11.99

Trading Card Singles | Sports Trading Cards | Sports Mem, Cards & Fan Shop |

 

Orville Wright Authenticated Ink REJECTED 1903 Indian Head Penny Card

$8.00

Trading Card Singles | Sports Trading Cards | Sports Mem, Cards & Fan Shop |

 

Alexander Graham Bell Authenticated Ink REJECTED 1899 Indian Head Penny Card

$8.00

Trading Card Singles | Sports Trading Cards | Sports Mem, Cards & Fan Shop |

 

PINEHURST (1895) Large GOLF BALL MARKER w/Indian Head Cent

$39.95

Golf | Fan Apparel & Souvenirs | Sports Mem, Cards & Fan Shop |

 

2003 Topps Gallery Currency Connection TY COBB Indian Head Penny GMA 10 Gem Mt

$59.95

Trading Card Singles | Sports Trading Cards | Sports Mem, Cards & Fan Shop |

 

Benjamin Franklin Authenticated Ink REJECTED 1899 Indian Head Penny Card

$11.99

Trading Card Singles | Sports Trading Cards | Sports Mem, Cards & Fan Shop |

 

Harriet Beecher Stowe Authenticated Ink REJECTED 1899 Indian Head Penny Card

$8.00

Trading Card Singles | Sports Trading Cards | Sports Mem, Cards & Fan Shop |

 

Framed Vintage 10 Cent Beer Night Baseball Cleveland Indians Flyer Gift

$44.98

Prints | Vintage Sports Memorabilia | Sports Mem, Cards & Fan Shop |

 

New Era Cleveland Guardians 59FIFTY Pay to Play Fitted Hat Size 7 1/8 New w/Tags

$19.99

Baseball-MLB | Fan Apparel & Souvenirs | Sports Mem, Cards & Fan Shop |

 

2018 Topps Stadium Club - Never Compromise - NC-AB - SO - Comp. Your Set - Mint

$1.99

Trading Card Singles | Sports Trading Cards | Sports Mem, Cards & Fan Shop |

 

Shane Bieber INDIANS/GUARDIANS (lot of 7)*2021x4+2022x2+2023x1*ONLY 58CENTS EACH

$2.69

Trading Card Lots | Sports Trading Cards | Sports Mem, Cards & Fan Shop |

 

Thomas Stevens Authenticated Ink REJECTED 1899 Indian Head Penny Card

$8.00

Trading Card Singles | Sports Trading Cards | Sports Mem, Cards & Fan Shop |

 

Cleveland Indians Diecut Sticker Vintage 10 cent Beer Night Municipal Stadium

$5.25

Baseball-MLB | Fan Apparel & Souvenirs | Sports Mem, Cards & Fan Shop |

 

Sir Barton Authenticated Ink 1919 Five-cent Indian Head Coin Card

$19.99

Trading Card Singles | Sports Trading Cards | Sports Mem, Cards & Fan Shop |

 

2003 Topps Baseball Cards (#501-721) + More: U Pick! 35 Cents Shipping/Discounts

$0.99

Trading Card Singles | Sports Trading Cards | Sports Mem, Cards & Fan Shop |

 

Walt Whitman REJECTED Authenticated Ink REJECTED 1899 Indian Head Penny Card

$8.00

Trading Card Singles | Sports Trading Cards | Sports Mem, Cards & Fan Shop |

 

2012 Topps Gypsy Queen Indian Head Penny Relic 2/10 Warren Spahn #IHP-WS HOF 1n0

$111.80

Trading Card Singles | Sports Trading Cards | Sports Mem, Cards & Fan Shop |

 

1963 MLB All Star Game Official Program Cleveland July 9 12x8in Metal Sign

$32.99

Baseball - MLB | Vintage Sports Memorabilia | Sports Mem, Cards & Fan Shop | Publications | Programs |

 

1996 Upper Deck USA #3 Anfernee Hardaway Orlando Magic

$2.54

Trading Card Singles | Sports Trading Cards | Sports Mem, Cards & Fan Shop |

 

2012 Topps Gypsy Queen Frank Thomas "Indian Head Penny" #/10 - Chicago White Sox

$174.99

Trading Card Singles | Sports Trading Cards | Sports Mem, Cards & Fan Shop |

 

AUTHENTICATED INK JOE GANS BOXING CARD 1902 INDIAN HEAD PENNY

$30.00

Trading Card Singles | Sports Trading Cards | Sports Mem, Cards & Fan Shop |

 

2012 Topps Gypsy Queen Miguel Cabrera Indian Head Penny IHP-MC # 01/10

$325.00

Trading Card Singles | Sports Trading Cards | Sports Mem, Cards & Fan Shop |

 

1987 WHK 1420 AM March Dimes Andy Allanson Cleveland Indians Autograph 4" Patch

$3.99

Patches | Vintage Sports Memorabilia | Sports Mem, Cards & Fan Shop |

 

Cleveland Indians Diecut Sticker Vintage 10 cent Beer Night Municipal Stadium

$5.25

Baseball-MLB | Fan Apparel & Souvenirs | Sports Mem, Cards & Fan Shop |

 

Art Ross Authenticated Ink 1907 Indian Head One-cent Coin Card

$24.99

Trading Card Singles | Sports Trading Cards | Sports Mem, Cards & Fan Shop |

 

2012 Topps Gypsy Queen Carlton Fisk "Indian Head Penny" #/10 - Boston Red Sox

$89.99

Trading Card Singles | Sports Trading Cards | Sports Mem, Cards & Fan Shop |

 

2020 Upper Deck US Currency Relic 1905 Indian Head Cent

$35.00

Trading Card Singles | Sports Trading Cards | Sports Mem, Cards & Fan Shop |

 

2012 Topps Gypsy Queen Indian Head Penny Relic 6/10 Ralph Kiner #IHP-RK HOF 5o5

$147.78

Trading Card Singles | Sports Trading Cards | Sports Mem, Cards & Fan Shop |

 

2020 UD GOODWIN CHAMPIONS 1900 INDIAN HEAD CENT HISTORIC CURRENCY

$50.00

Trading Card Singles | Sports Trading Cards | Sports Mem, Cards & Fan Shop |

 

Muhammad Ali Lot, 1991 AW Sports 69 PSA 9, Authentic Ink 1860 Indian Head Penny+

$99.99

Trading Card Lots | Sports Trading Cards | Sports Mem, Cards & Fan Shop |

 

Charles Darwin REJECTED Authenticated Ink REJECTED 1899 Indian Head Penny Card

$10.00

Trading Card Singles | Sports Trading Cards | Sports Mem, Cards & Fan Shop |

 

Cleveland Indians BB 10 Cent Beer Night (6/6/1974) T-Shirt, Men's 2XL, Blue Gray

$15.00

Baseball-MLB | Fan Apparel & Souvenirs | Sports Mem, Cards & Fan Shop |

 

99 Cents Baseball Cards Cleveland Guardians(Indians) You Pick! Updated 10-11-25

$0.99

Trading Card Singles | Sports Trading Cards | Sports Mem, Cards & Fan Shop |

 

Fleer Baseball Team Logo Sticker Singles (1987-1991) U Pick, 35 Cent Shipping!

$1.09

Trading Card Singles | Sports Trading Cards | Sports Mem, Cards & Fan Shop |

 

2021 Topps Allen & Ginter Baseball - Rallying Back - .99 Cents Shipping

$1.00

Trading Card Singles | Sports Trading Cards | Sports Mem, Cards & Fan Shop |

 

1999 Cleveland Indians Tribe Talk Third Quarter, Guardians

$1.49

Other Vint. Sport Publications | Vintage Sports Memorabilia | Sports Mem, Cards & Fan Shop | Publications |

 

2012 Rare SP Gypsy Queen Baseball Cal Ripken Jr. Indian Head Penny Insert 06/10

$1,999.00

Trading Card Singles | Sports Trading Cards | Sports Mem, Cards & Fan Shop |

 

2005 Topps Baseball Card Singles (#508-734) + OPENING DAY: U Pick! 50 Cent Ship!

$1.49

Trading Card Singles | Sports Trading Cards | Sports Mem, Cards & Fan Shop |

 

2006 Topps Baseball Card Singles (#251-500): U Pick! 35 Cent Shipping!

$0.99

Trading Card Singles | Sports Trading Cards | Sports Mem, Cards & Fan Shop |

 

HOF 1939-46 BOB FELLER Cleveland Indians penny arcade Exhibit baseball card

$79.99

Trading Card Singles | Sports Trading Cards | Sports Mem, Cards & Fan Shop |

 

1994 Donruss Rated Rookie #322 Manny Ramirez Cleveland Indians BASEBALL Card 3C

$4.29

Trading Card Singles | Sports Trading Cards | Sports Mem, Cards & Fan Shop |

 

2010 Panini Century 3 Cent Stamp Bob Feller Auto Issue #38 PSA 9! Indians! POP 1

$149.99

Trading Card Singles | Sports Trading Cards | Sports Mem, Cards & Fan Shop |

 

1939-46 Exhibits Jeff Heath Baseball Arcade SGC Graded Cleveland Indians

$79.99

Trading Card Singles | Sports Trading Cards | Sports Mem, Cards & Fan Shop |

 

1961 Topps Baseball Cards Singles: U Pick, 35 Cent Shipping!

$3.49

Trading Card Singles | Sports Trading Cards | Sports Mem, Cards & Fan Shop |

 

1961 Post Cereal (F278-33) #57 Harvey Kuenn Box Version, Cleveland Indians

$4.00

Trading Card Singles | Sports Trading Cards | Sports Mem, Cards & Fan Shop |

 

1962 Topps #NNO Barry Latman Stamps Cleveland Indians

$2.79

Trading Card Singles | Sports Trading Cards | Sports Mem, Cards & Fan Shop |

 

1960 Topps RC #122 Don Dillard Cleveland Indians BASEBALL Card 5C

$8.99

Trading Card Singles | Sports Trading Cards | Sports Mem, Cards & Fan Shop |

 

HOF 1939-46 LOU BOUDREAU Cleveland Indians penny arcade Exhibit baseball card

$49.99

Trading Card Singles | Sports Trading Cards | Sports Mem, Cards & Fan Shop |

 

Joe Gordon Cleveland Indians 1960 Topps #216 HOF Oregon Ducks 5C

$4.86

Trading Card Singles | Sports Trading Cards | Sports Mem, Cards & Fan Shop |

 

2013 Topps Allen and Ginter Baseball #1-250 - Finish Your Set *GOTBASEBALLCARDS

$0.99

Trading Card Singles | Sports Trading Cards | Sports Mem, Cards & Fan Shop |

 

2011 Bowman #TP76 Jason Kipnis Topps 100 Cleveland Indians 3C

$1.99

Trading Card Singles | Sports Trading Cards | Sports Mem, Cards & Fan Shop |

 

1963 SALADA JUNKET COIN JOHN ROMANO #46 CLEVELAND INDIANS

$2.00

Coins | Vintage Sports Memorabilia | Sports Mem, Cards & Fan Shop |

 

1962 Exhibits Tito Francona Baseball Arcade Card SGC Graded Cleveland Indians

$39.99

Trading Card Singles | Sports Trading Cards | Sports Mem, Cards & Fan Shop |

 

1980 Topps Baseball Card Singles (#1-389) LOW GRADE: U Pick! 35 Cent Ship!

$0.99

Trading Card Singles | Sports Trading Cards | Sports Mem, Cards & Fan Shop |

 

New Cleveland Indians Baseball MLB Long Sleeve Shirt Majestic Blue XL Quarter

$50.00

Baseball-MLB | Fan Apparel & Souvenirs | Sports Mem, Cards & Fan Shop |

 

1960 Topps #112 Jack Harshman Cleveland Indians BASEBALL Card 5C

$5.99

Trading Card Singles | Sports Trading Cards | Sports Mem, Cards & Fan Shop |

 

1947-1966 DALE MITCHELL Cleveland Indians penny arcade Exhibit baseball card

$9.99

Trading Card Singles | Sports Trading Cards | Sports Mem, Cards & Fan Shop |

 

1953 Topps Baseball #153 JIM FRIDLEY OF Indians EX...93 CENT SHIPPING!

$10.00

Trading Card Singles | Sports Trading Cards | Sports Mem, Cards & Fan Shop |

 

1947-66 Exhibits Jim Hegan Baseball Arcade Card SGC Graded Cleveland Indians

$69.99

Trading Card Singles | Sports Trading Cards | Sports Mem, Cards & Fan Shop |

 

1960 Topps #63 George Strickland Cleveland Indians BASEBALL Card 3C

$4.49

Trading Card Singles | Sports Trading Cards | Sports Mem, Cards & Fan Shop |

 

1947-66 Exhibits Hank Majeski Baseball Arcade Card SGC Graded Cleveland Indians

$59.99

Trading Card Singles | Sports Trading Cards | Sports Mem, Cards & Fan Shop |

 

2006 Topps Turkey Red Baseball Complete Your Set (316-630)

$1.25

Trading Card Singles | Sports Trading Cards | Sports Mem, Cards & Fan Shop |

 

2019 Topps Series 1 - Regular - Cards 1-350 - U Pick Complete Your Set - Mint

$1.99

Trading Card Singles | Sports Trading Cards | Sports Mem, Cards & Fan Shop |

 

1939-46 JOE GORDON Cleveland Indians penny arcade Exhibit baseball card

$49.99

Trading Card Singles | Sports Trading Cards | Sports Mem, Cards & Fan Shop |

 

2007 Topps ALLEN and GINTER RCs SPs ⚾ YOU PICK YOUR FAVS 🧢 MLB BASEBALL CARDS

$1.79

Trading Card Singles | Sports Trading Cards | Sports Mem, Cards & Fan Shop |

 

JULIO FRANCO RARE U.S. BASEBALL 30 CENT STAMP CARD CLEVELAND INDIANS

$2.99

Trading Card Singles | Sports Trading Cards | Sports Mem, Cards & Fan Shop |

 

1960 Topps #376 Johnny Briggs Cleveland Indians BASEBALL Card 3C

$5.49

Trading Card Singles | Sports Trading Cards | Sports Mem, Cards & Fan Shop |

 

2018 Topps Heritage - Base Set - Cards 1-500 - U Pick Complete Your Set - Mint

$1.99

Trading Card Singles | Sports Trading Cards | Sports Mem, Cards & Fan Shop |

 

2018 Topps Series 1 - Base Set - Cards 1-350 - U Pick Complete Your Set - Mint

$1.99

Trading Card Singles | Sports Trading Cards | Sports Mem, Cards & Fan Shop |

 

Yasiel Puig 2015 Topps Coin & Stamp Rare Insert Penny And Stamp #14/50 B3

$19.95

Trading Card Singles | Sports Trading Cards | Sports Mem, Cards & Fan Shop |

 

Lot of 5 Issues Cleveland Indians Tribe Talk Newsletter Fourth Quarter 2000

$5.00

Other Vint. Sport Publications | Vintage Sports Memorabilia | Sports Mem, Cards & Fan Shop | Publications |

 

1980 Topps #141 Gary Alexander Cleveland Indians BASEBALL Card 3C

$3.99

Trading Card Singles | Sports Trading Cards | Sports Mem, Cards & Fan Shop |

 

Authenticated Ink - Walter Johnson 1936 Lincoln Wheat Cent Card - The Big Train

$15.95

Trading Card Singles | Sports Trading Cards | Sports Mem, Cards & Fan Shop |

 

2009 Topps Heritage Chrome Baseball - Finish Your Set *GOTBASEBALLCARDS

$2.96

Trading Card Singles | Sports Trading Cards | Sports Mem, Cards & Fan Shop |

 

1983 Topps Baseball Card Singles: U Pick! 35 Cent Shipping + Discounts!

$1.79

Trading Card Singles | Sports Trading Cards | Sports Mem, Cards & Fan Shop |

 

1975 Topps #377 Tom Hilgendorf Cleveland Indians BASEBALL Card 3C

$4.99

Trading Card Singles | Sports Trading Cards | Sports Mem, Cards & Fan Shop |

 

2018 Topps Update Series - International Affair - Cards IA-1-50 - U Pick - Mint

$1.99

Trading Card Singles | Sports Trading Cards | Sports Mem, Cards & Fan Shop |

 

LOT (75) 2025 Topps Series Two: Cleveland Guardians - 25 Cents Per Base Card

$18.75

Trading Card Lots | Sports Trading Cards | Sports Mem, Cards & Fan Shop |

 

1980 Topps #252 Ted Cox Cleveland Indians BASEBALL Card 3C

$3.99

Trading Card Singles | Sports Trading Cards | Sports Mem, Cards & Fan Shop |